Carraway Dam
A civic achievement, quietly waiting for a capacity for growth that never arrived.
Completed in 1951 by the Appalachian Energy & Mine Commission, the Carraway Dam was heralded as the centerpiece of the region’s post-war electrification drive. Spanning the upper Carraway Gorge with 340 feet of reinforced concrete, the structure was built as a hydroelectric powerhouse to give the valley cheap current and loosen its dependence on coal: power for the homes and works of Mill Hollow and the lines running down the gorge to the rest of Cambray County.
The first dam
There had been a dam at Carraway before. In the 1870s the Tuckseed Sportsmen’s Club, a retreat for Pittsburgh steel and coal men, built an earthen dam across the upper Tuckseed to hold a summer lake for its members. In 1889, after days of rain, it gave way, and the flood went down the Gorge and the Little Conemaw and through Jonestown. More than two thousand people died. The club’s members were sued and none was ever held responsible. The Gorge stood empty for twenty years afterwards.
So the Commission’s plan to dam the Tuckseed again was never simply popular. The Hollow wanted the power and the work; Jonestown remembered 1889; the Cambray Iron & Steel Company, which sold the county its coal, fought it at every hearing. The Commission promised concrete where the club had piled earth, and won.
Construction
The project broke ground in 1948 under the supervision of chief engineer Elias Morrow, funded through the Commission’s federal infrastructure allocation. Workers, many of them veterans, were housed in the purpose-built Carraway Workers’ Camp, traces of which remain on the eastern bank.
Operations
The dam reached full capacity in 1953 and operated without major incident through the early 1970s. A 1967 inspection report praised its structural integrity and noted that the reservoir had never been drawn below the 60% mark, suggesting “capacity for growth that never arrived” - a phrase the Commission’s own communications office used in a 1969 public bulletin.
Decommissioning
By 1978, shifting energy policy, cheaper power from the regional grid and a valley that had largely emptied left the dam economically unviable. The Commission formally transferred custody to the county in 1981. The structure has been maintained at minimal operating status since.
See also: Carraway Dam (Declassified) for the classified record. Spoilers.
Tribune files
Records from the Cambray Tribune about this place. Each is sealed; the number printed on the copy found in the county opens it.
- Carraway Dam Dedication, 1951 (Tribune photo, 1951 (Tribune archive))